No Recession in the First Quarter Despite a Decline in Real GDP...

Bill Adams

Economic Chart

No Recession in the First Quarter Despite a Decline in Real GDP; Consumer Spending, Fixed Investment, and Employment Rose Solidly

• Yikes! Real GDP contracted at a 1.4% annualized pace in the first quarter of 2022.
• A jump in the trade deficit was the biggest factor behind the first quarter’s drop in GDP.
• Government spending fell and businesses added less to inventories, which compounded the decline.
• By contrast, consumer spending and fixed investment grew solidly in the quarter.
• The solid growth of these two GDP components, as well as recent strong employment growth, are clear signs that the U.S. economy was not in a recession at the beginning of the year.
• Real GDP growth should resume in the second quarter as the trade deficit and inventories pose smaller headwinds.
• The Fed will look past this stinker of a GDP report and raise the federal funds rate by half a percentage point at their May 4 Federal Open Market Committee meeting.

Real GDP was considerably worse than expected in the first quarter of 2022, contracting at a 1.4% annualized pace; Comerica had forecast 1.2% growth and the consensus 1.0% growth. Three components of end demand were behind the first quarter’s surprise contraction (See chart on second page). The largest was net exports, which subtracted 3.2 percentage points from the annualized change in real GDP. Of this, 2.5 percentage points was from real imports surging to a new record high. This is a knock-on effect of the huge backlog of ships that were waiting to unload at U.S. ports at the end of 2021. Their cargos were finally delivered in the first quarter of 2022, which is usually a seasonal lull for U.S. purchases of foreign products. As a result, seasonally-adjusted imports jumped. In addition, a fall in goods exports subtracted 0.8 percentage points from annualized growth after adding 1.6 percentage points in the fourth quarter of 2021. Giveback from a strong fourth quarter, the appreciation of the dollar, lockdowns in China, and spillover from the Russia-Ukraine war weighed on U.S. exports in the first quarter.

Inventory restocking subtracted another 0.8 percentage points from the annualized change in real GDP in the first quarter, after adding 5.3 percentage points in the fourth quarter of 2021 and adding 2.2 percentage points in the third quarter. Businesses still added to inventories in the first quarter, but at a slower pace than in the prior quarter, and it is the change in the change in inventories which shows up as an addition or subtraction to the change in real GDP. Some of the slower inventory build was because businesses wanted higher inventories but product wasn’t available. This was apparent in the motor vehicle industry, where sales rose on the quarter but inventories fell. Some of the slower inventory build was from businesses who could’ve bought more but chose not to. PMI surveys show businesses faced fewer delivery delays in the first quarter than in the worst months of 2021. Since supply chains are functioning better, there is less need for precautionary inventories. 

Finally, government consumption and investment subtracted another 0.5 percentage points from the change in real GDP in the first quarter, of which 0.3 percentage points was from lower national defense spending. State and local government spending subtracted another 0.1 percentage point. These GDP components say little about where the economy sits in the business cycle.

By contrast, the core components of GDP looked quite good in the first quarter, namely consumer spending and fixed investment. Real personal consumption expenditures on goods were flat. Consumers spent more on durable goods, in particular motor vehicles and parts as the chip shortage became less of a drag on new vehicle availability. But they cut back on nondurable goods purchases; volumes of energy goods consumed fell as their prices rose. Consumer spending on services added a big 1.9 percentage points to annualized growth in the first quarter as Americans spent more on health care, housing, restaurants, and other services.

Fixed investment added 1.3 percentage points to the annualized change in real GDP in the first quarter and grew the fastest since the first quarter of 2021. Nonresidential investment in business equipment grew solidly, as did spending on intellectual property products like software. Supply chain problems held back growth of construction activity, though. Real residential investment rose modestly, while investment in nonresidential structures was flat.

From a year earlier, real GDP grew 3.6% in the first quarter of 2022, down from 5.5% growth in the fourth quarter of 2021. Another way to think of the soft first quarter is that there was giveback after growth in the fourth quarter of 2021 (6.9% annualized!) was distorted higher by a huge inventory build. Compared with two quarters earlier, real GDP in the first quarter of 2022 was up at a 2.7% annualized rate—not shabby by any means.

A negative GDP print inevitably raises questions about recession risk. Two consecutive quarters of contracting real GDP is often thought of as a convenient shorthand measure of a recession (Though the poindexters in economics departments use a qualitative measure that also considers data on employment, production, and income). While real GDP did fall in the first quarter, the GDP report’s details do not look recessionary. Nor, for that matter, does the quarter’s other economic data, like its robust 562,000 monthly increase in nonfarm payroll employment. Real GDP will return to growth in the second quarter as trade and inventories become less of a drag. But over the rest of this year, growth of discretionary consumer spending will likely slow as higher food and energy prices continue to erode disposable income, and the effects of crisis-era stimulus programs fade. In year-over-year terms, real GDP growth will likely moderate from 3.6% in the first quarter of 2022 to 2.0% in the fourth quarter of the year.

The first quarter’s decline in real GDP will not stop the Fed from raising interest rates at their next decision on Wednesday May 4, since the components of GDP that best reflect the economy’s momentum—consumer spending and fixed investment—performed well in the quarter.  Comerica forecasts for the Fed to raise the federal funds target half a percentage point, to a range of one half to three quarters of a percent, and to announce a plan to reduce the size of their balance sheet by over half a trillion dollars by the end of this year, with more reductions down the line. The Fed is set to raise the federal funds rate by another half percentage point at their June decision.

Investment and Consumption Components Economic Chart

The articles and opinions in this publication are for general information only, are subject to change without notice, and are not intended to provide specific investment, legal, accounting, tax or other advice or recommendations. The information and/or views contained herein reflect the thoughts and opinions of the noted authors only, and such information and/or views do not necessarily reflect the thoughts and opinions of Comerica or its management team. This publication is being provided without any warranty whatsoever. Any opinion referenced in this publication may not come to pass. We are not offering or soliciting any transaction based on this information. You should consult your attorney, accountant or tax or financial advisor with regard to your situation before taking any action that may have legal, tax or financial consequences. Although the information in this publication has been obtained from sources we believe to be reliable, neither the authors nor Comerica guarantee its timeliness or accuracy, and such information may be incomplete or condensed. Neither the authors nor Comerica shall be liable for any typographical errors or incorrect data obtained from reliable sources or factual information.

Comerica Economic Commentary Newsletter Sign-up

April 28, 2022
Bil Adams, Senior Vice President and Chief Economist at Comerica Bank

Bill Adams

Senior Vice President and Chief Economist

Related Content