Comerica logo
Personal FinanceSmall BusinessCorporateWealth Management
About ComericaBranch/ATM LocatorHelp CenterContact Us
Personal Finance
Home > Personal Finance > Investing > IRAs > Compare our IRAs
Print This Page
Compare our IRAs
Purpose
Features
Eligibility
Withdrawal
Contribution Limits
Traditional IRA
Retirement savings

First time home purchases

Higher education expenses
Earnings accumulate tax deferred.

Contributions may be tax deductible.

Deductible contribution thresholds increase yearly.
Not yet reached age 70 ½

AND

Compensation earned during the year
Required minimum distributions at age 70 ½2

IRA penalty-free withdrawal events2:
  • First-time home purchase ($10,000 lifetime cap) 
  • Qualifying expenses, such as Educational and Medical expenses, and Health Insurance (if unemployed)
  • Age 59 ½
  • Disability
  • IRS Tax Levy
  • Death
Limited to the following, or 100% of earned compensation, whichever is less:
  • Tax years 2005, 2006, 2007: $4,000
  • Tax years 2008 and beyond: $5,000
No more than maximum annual contribution amount may be contributed between a Traditional IRA and a Roth IRA combined

Individuals age 50+ can make Catch-up Contributions in addition to annual contribution limit:
  • Tax year 2005: $500
  • 2006 and beyond: $1,000
Spousal IRA
Working spouse sets up for non-working spouse
Varies based on type. See Traditional or Roth IRA.
Traditional and Roth IRAs:
Couple must file joint return

Traditional IRA only:
Non-working spouse for whom the contribution is being made must not have attained age 70 ½.

Contribution may be deductible if one spouse not active participant in an employer-sponsored retirement plan.

Roth IRA only:
AGI1 less than $160,000

Spousal contributions can continue even after non-working spouse attains age 70 ½ (as long as working spouse qualifies)
Varies.

Same as Traditional IRA or Roth IRA
Same as Traditional IRA
Roth IRA
Retirement savings

First time home purchases
Contributions after tax

Earnings accumulate tax free

No age restrictions but must meet AGI1 limitations

Qualified distributions are tax free

Convertible from a regular IRA if AGI is under $100,000
AGI1 must be below $95,000 (single)
OR
$150,000 (married filing jointly)

If AGI exceeds limits, partial contributions possible5
No required minimum distributions at age 70 ½

After 5 years, the following are IRS penalty-free withdrawal events2:
  • First-time home purchase ($10,000 lifetime cap)
  • Age 59 ½
  • Disability
  • Death
Same as Traditional IRA
SEP IRA
For Self-employed individuals
OR
Small business owners
Easy to establish and maintain

Low cost

Minimal IRS filings and paperwork

Flexible employer contribution limits

Employer not committed to contribute for any future years


No age limitations provided that income is still being earned
Must include all employees who are:

At least age 21
AND
Have earned at least $450 in 3 of last 5 years

May exclude:
  • Union Employees
  • Certain non-resident aliens (no age requirements)
Same as Traditional IRA
Limited to $41,000
OR
25% of earned annual compensation based on the first $205,000 of compensation)

Whichever is less
SIMPLE IRA
For self-employed individuals
OR
Small business owners with 100 or fewer employees
Easy to establish and maintain

Tax-deferred earnings

Pretax contributions may reduce employee's current taxable income

100% immediate participant vesting
Must include all employees who:

have earned at least $5,000 during 2 preceding years
AND
who can expect to earn $5,000 in current year

May exclude:
  • Union Employees
  • Certain non-resident aliens
Same as Traditional IRA
Participants may defer up to $10,000 a year

Employer must match deferrals, dollar-for-dollar, up to 3% of compensation4
OR
Employer can make a 2% compensation contribution for each eligible employee
Rollover IRA
Maintain tax advantages when leaving your job.

Roll over previous retirement account to an IRA
OR
Roll over Traditional IRA to a Roth IRA
Avoid 20% tax withholding with a "direct" rollover ('trustee to trustee")

Use IRA Rollover for penalty-free, short-term (less than 60 days) borrowing source3.
Deposit proceeds to rollover IRA within 60 days of receipt (including weekends and holidays)
Varies.

See Traditional IRA or Roth IRA.
Not applicable.
DISCLOSURES:
Securities offered by Comerica Securities are NOT FDIC insured, are not deposits or obligations of, or guaranteed by Comerica Bank or any of its affiliates, and involve risk, including possible loss of principal. Comerica Securities is a broker/dealer, member FINRA/SIPC, and a subsidiary of Comerica Bank.

Comerica Securities does not provide tax or legal advice. Please consult a tax or legal advisor regarding your situation.

1AGI: Adjusted Gross Income

2All other withdrawals are subject to an IRS early distribution penalty. Consult your tax advisor.

3The money can be deposited back into the same IRA account it came from, or into a different account. However, each account subject to this restriction: only one rollover deposit allowed during any 365-day period. If these guidelines are violated, you will be liable for a 10% withdrawal penalty (for premature withdrawal).

4This amount can be lowered to 1% in 2 out of 5 years.

5Partial contributions allowed if AGI between $95,000 and $110,000 (single) or $150,000 and $160,000 (married filing jointly)







Comerica.com - English
Comerica.com - Spanish